10.25.2011

Cheap Crap Isn't Value.

Pushing revenue growth like a mid-block, sweaty-summer yard-sale party isn’t the secret to creating sustainable business growth.  It isn’t creating value.

Over the last seven decades, businesses have  tried just about everything to get noticed — from editorials to magazine articles to coupons, “blowout weekends”, flash sales, QR codes, and now discount services like Living Social and Groupon.

And all to create a feeling among buyers that they are getting extraordinary value.

It’s artificial fluff.

Because it’s just cheap crap sold in a Maserati paint job.

It’s usually value created with short-term pricing changes.  Or at best a misguided sense of exclusivity or elitism.

And it’s crippling our business potential.

As quickly as businesses have evolved to understand the need for value, the idea of how to create that value has become even more mysterious.

More confused and frustrating.

It’s painfully clear in our results.

Consumers take less interest in special deals. And shop owners see significantly less return-on-investment from their failing attempts at creating value.

Which begs the question: “Do we even know how to create value?”

Do we know what value is?

It begs explanation.

“The hardest part about creating value is understanding that it’s not you that decides if it’s valuable or not.”

Your opinion doesn’t matter.

And perhaps that’s where our problems with creating value have spiraled out of control.

As the economy continues to spiral downward, we’ve shifted our focus away from the people we serve to the failure we hope to avoid.

We’ve become consumed with surviving.  And it’s made us think we can sell crap and call it valuable.

It has no value.

“It isn’t valuable. It’s selfishness thinly disguised as discerning business strategy.”

Value is something all together different.

It’s a combination of key factors that all contribute to a feeling of delight.

Here’s a quick roadmap to those factors.  To the key ingredients in creating value:

  • V = Validates unspoken concerns — Value provides a solution to a deeply personal problem that we are afraid to admit.  It’s not just the “skin deep” reasons that we try to use in public.  Real value solves confidence problems, love problems, money problems — the gritty nasty side of life buyers try to pretend isn’t there.  Discounts and  artificial pricing don’t fix those problems.
  • A = Actionable opportunity  – Value is an activity you can grab right now.  It isn’t just an idea.  It’s an opportunity that can be taken advantage of when you hear about it.  It does no good to talk up  a super-duper fantastical experience and then demand that buyers wait to start doing anything about it.  Less hype.  More happening.
  • L = Leverages social approval — Value is something that you can be proud of.  It’s something that you can share with your friends and not be be ashamed of.  It’s an opportunity where you gain social standing by being the first to spot it.  If buyers can’t convince their friends it’s a good deal then the deal probably isn’t good enough.  Do better.
  • U = Understated corporate presence — Value is personal not professional.  So less is more.  Buyers want to feel like they are getting a good deal — not that they are pulling a  ”fast one”.  You can drive increased customer loyalty by down-playing the grandiose nature of your offer — even if it significant.  Connecting with people as a person yourself is a better strategy.
  • E = Emotionally targeted message — Value is emotional not logical.  Even if the discount actually is the outrageous ratio you have listed on the sticker, buyers don’t give a hoot.  The deal is only as good as it feels  like it is.  Which is why you have to start with the emotions of the buyer.  Make people feel special and you won’t have to drop your price so much

Creating value is tough.

One big reason behind that is because it’s not about you.  It’s about the other guy.

And that means less control for us.  Less certainty.

And hopefully less crap.

No one really wants cheap in the first place.


  • http://www.joemcgonigal.com Joe

    This is great post.

    This sentence is the key – “The hardest part about creating value is understanding that it’s not you that decides if it’s valuable or not.”

    • http://www.DanWaldschmidt.com/ Dan Waldschmidt

      Thanks, Joe…

      I have read a lot of books and articles on value and this is one of those things that seems to be missing in most of them.

      Dan

      p.s. Thanks for stopping by and sharing. Stop back by again, ok?

  • http://www.joemcgonigal.com Joe

    This is great post.

    This sentence is the key – “The hardest part about creating value is understanding that it’s not you that decides if it’s valuable or not.”

  • http://www.linkedin.com/pub/tim-mushey/8/428/305 Tim Mushey

    This is great stuff Dan! Hopefully it will get people thinking today.
     
    One of the models that I used to work under was the “lowest price possible & hope for high volume sales”. Of course that was not sustainable long term. It is way to easy to assume that you cannot sell quality, valuable products and services when times are tough, and that certainly may be the case in some instances.

    But overall, people don’t want cheap, less valuable products. There is short term gain, long term pain with that philosophy. Cheap crap breaks down faster, and causes more issues on the back end. So it comes around full circle. Buy the good stuff that has value, and have fewer headaches. Thanks again!

    • http://www.DanWaldschmidt.com/ Dan Waldschmidt

      You nailed it, Tim.

      People may “SAY” that they want the cheapest price possible, but really they want a fair price and the feeling that they achieved something special. Give them more of the latter and you won’t have to drop your price so darn much.

      Dan

  • http://www.linkedin.com/pub/tim-mushey/8/428/305 Tim Mushey

    This is great stuff Dan! Hopefully it will get people thinking today.
     
    One of the models that I used to work under was the “lowest price possible & hope for high volume sales”. Of course that was not sustainable long term. It is way to easy to assume that you cannot sell quality, valuable products and services when times are tough, and that certainly may be the case in some instances.

    But overall, people don’t want cheap, less valuable products. There is short term gain, long term pain with that philosophy. Cheap crap breaks down faster, and causes more issues on the back end. So it comes around full circle. Buy the good stuff that has value, and have fewer headaches. Thanks again!

  • http://carouselsalesblog.blogspot.com Cara Celli

    I know your intention was not to be funny, but I couldn’t help but laugh when you said,”nobody really wants crap in the first place!”

    Unless they’re just looking for something to “get them by”, then they’re looking for the best value for the money they have to spend…

    Personally, I want the best for the money I have to spend on a product, even if I feel like it’s a lot. Consumers need to be reminded about the long term, not just the instant gratification of finding some junk nobody else wanted. 

    • http://www.DanWaldschmidt.com/ Dan Waldschmidt

      I am delighted that you found this humorous. It does put a smile on your face — probably because its all too ironically true. :-)

      Dan

  • Anonymous

    Dan, nailed it.
    At the end of the day, it comes down to providing a bona fide solution to a problem.  Too often, people develop “solutions looking for problems” and wonder why they can never sustain long term growth.

    BTW – If I get a Maserati paint job on my VW, you think it will do 190 MPH???

    • http://www.DanWaldschmidt.com/ Dan Waldschmidt

      Dave,

      You are dead right.

      Just because you have a “solution” doesn’t mean there is a problem…

      Dan

      p.s. I do think a Maserati paint job would be a fun bet after all.

twitter logo picture facebook logo picture linkedin logo picture rss logo picture
Waldschmidt Logo
twitter logo picture facebook logo picture linkedin logo picture rss logo picture
Waldschmidt Logo